Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
I could be swayed if everyone else thinks he's probably full of it.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
OK, I get you. Although I'll note that you're not exactly helping me decide who I should definitely vote for.  |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
Hmmm, if true, this is pretty convincing. And I can't imagine you'd lie about something all the other experienced players would be able to easily confirm, so I think I'll defer to your guys' experience on this one and toss that theory for finding scum.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
Fair enough. If it helps, I'm not at all certain you're scum, but I'll probably see what other people say about my vote before I change it.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
Fair enough, and I'm definitely open to changing my vote if people have a better candidate in mind, but
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giraffe
It's just a gut feeling, so I could probably be talked out of it, but
|
Giraffe: this is your first game. I get that. I also get that some/several of these comments were joking with folks. I would note, however, that continuing to say that your votes are flexible depending on what other people do suggests that you are not choosing based only on your own thoughts, but by what other folks do. I would say that's anti-Town, because you don't know what alignment anyone else is, unless you're Scum (well, or Mason, but since we don't know about the presence of them I'm ignoring that as an option).
So, fair warning.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Special Ed
The downside? The downside of what? of Bear's though that Batman must find him because of his name?
|
I was reading him as taking a guess that Batman would have to do an action to find him or investigate, rather than that Batman would out himself at large. I agree that, from what he's said, he has no basis for that.